I knew I could count on you, Internets! For those of you who are interested, here are the results. I'm only including things that got more than one vote, and I'm grouping by brand (meaning that while there were a few specific Oil of Olay products mentioned, I tallied each mention as a general vote for Oil of Olay). Here goes:
Oil of Olay (14 votes)
Lots and lots of others got one vote each. I have yet to buy anything, but I have a plan. I'm going to get some Oil of Olay for daily use and then get the Philosophy for nighttime. A few people pointed out that there's no need for SPF at night (duh!) and since I have sensitive skin, it's best not to use potentially irritating ingredients when I don't need to. I just hate having two products where one will do.
I'll let you know both products work out for me. I admit to being skeptical about the Olay; I think of that brand as something for grandmas, even though all of the votes are a clear indication that it's not! Must adjust my mindset. As for the Philosophy, I love the look of their products and am glad that the results have been as good as the look for many of you.